Who Would Jesus Vote For?

So, on our most recent podcast (episode 37), Frank and I discussed how far off America was from the possibility of an atheist candidate being elected to the Presidency of the United States. The answer: pretty fucking far. However, new evidence seems to show that we’re not quite as far off as we may have thought.

The question was prompted by an email from a listener named Andrew who just COULDN’T STOP BRAGGING about how great his homeland of Australia is, ’cause they have “an unmarried atheist female prime minister.” OOOOHHHH! Your Country is soooooo much better than ours, isn’t it Andrew? SO MATURE! “Look at us, we’re Australia. We elect people based on how we think they’ll do in office, rather than irrelevant, extraneous details about their personal lives….” Grow up, Australia.

There are two points I want to make here. The first is that in a parliamentary system, you don’t elect a PM. I’m guessing that Julia Gillard (yeah, that’s right- I googled the shit out of this mo-fo) might have had a tougher time getting the PM position if she had to convince the entire Country to vote her into it. Being elected to a seat in the House of Representatives is by no means an easy feat, but it’s certainly easier than a presidential election. I’m not saying that Aussies absolutely wouldn’t elect a woman like Ms. Gillard to a presidency, I’m just saying it would’ve been a tougher road.

My second point (which I had to think about for a while because having ADHD means that you can forget point b in the course of writing out point a) is that Americans are actually getting closer to being reasonable about the whole atheist thing. Bastion of journalistic excellence USA Today reported on a new poll which showed that over half of Americans (barely over half: 54%) would vote for a “well-qualified” atheist candidate. Mind you- what the poll actually shows is that 54% of Americans will now tell a pollster that they would vote for an atheist, but that’s still an improvement over past polls.

Wonder who that guy voted for...

Actual representation of what happens when you vote for an atheist.

Mind you, as the article points out, atheists are still behind every other group they asked about, including homos and Muslims (I don’t think they asked about homo Muslims), but I still have hope. Considering that when they started asking this question back in 1958 the non-believers were pulling a solid 18%, we’re showing some real progress. We may be only 10-20 years behind the rest of the civilized world, instead of 30!

Go us! U.S.A.! U.S.A.!

3 thoughts on “Who Would Jesus Vote For?

  1. Aussies ! Always bragging . I’m from NZ ( whole ‘nother country ) and I do tend to agree with him a wee bit. Downunder , if you stand up hand on heart and say you believe in god and ‘god bless …wherever ” you’re more likely to LOSE votes and be looked on as ‘flakey’ . .. I often hear things like ” they’re a STRANGE family , they all go to church ” ..or ” oh he’s a real god botherer that one ” … lol ! You have to love it !!

  2. Hey Guys, I love your podcast. My gf and I listen to almost every one. I don’t see a way to contact you on your page here, so I hope you get this message. I will be speaking at the U of Utah on my new book Sex and God: How Religion Distorts Sexuality, Sept. 14-16 at their mini conference on sexuality. I am also author of The God Virus which you may be familiar with. It would be great to meet you and maybe have a beer. Hope to see you.


  3. Guys- I love your podcast but after listening to “The Jesus Episode” again, I hope you don’t have Rachel on again any time soon. It was like listening to a whiny Valley Girl complain about EVERYTHING being wrong. No, Rachel- the Olympic athletes aren’t just in the competition because they are the ones who are the rich kids. And it’s wrong to be competitive because Americans just act so superior when we win a medal. And the Fourth of July is wrong, patriotism is wrong, wah,wah,wah. I hate being critical because I just adore Frank and she is his friend, but this is the only episode that actually annoys me and I try to avoid repeat listenings. Like, totally……..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *